Talmud su I Re 2:49

How for kings? If he died in Adar and a king took office in Adar it is counted as a year for both of them. Rebbi Jonah said, only if he reached Nisan. Otherwise like the following, he ruled one month in Samaria⁴⁵2K. 15:13. If he had ruled longer, it would have counted for a year.. You can determine the years of the kings of Israel only through the years of the kings of Jehudah, and you can determine the years of the kings of Jehudah only through the years of the kings of Israel⁴⁶Since there were overlapping years at the start and end of each reign, and there might have been shifts between Western counting from Nisan and Eastern counting from Tishre, the correspondences given in Kings are necessary to establish the correct correspondences. This leaves uncertainty for the days of the united monarchy.. It is written⁴⁷1K. 2:11.: And the time that David ruled over Israel was forty years, etc. And it is written⁴⁸2S.5:4. Then according to the rules given earlier, the reign should have been counted as 41 years. Cf. Babli Sanhedrin107a/b., in Hebron he ruled over Jehudah seven years and six months, etc. In total they are deficient and in detail excessive. Rebbi Isaac bar Qaṣaṣata in the name of Rebbi Jonah: they were thirty-two and a half years, but to honor Jerusalem he counts them as entire. The great Jehudah says, the greater number absorbs the lesser⁴⁹But according to our rules, the numbers should have been rounded up, not down.. ⁵⁰The following sentence is from Berakhot2:1 (Notes 66–67), also Mo`ed qatan3:7 (83d l.4). As answer to the problem of the excess 6 months it is unsatisfactory. Rebbi Samuel bar Naḥman said, when your days will be complete⁵¹2S. 7:12.. The Holy One, praise to Him, said to David: I am counting full days for you, I am not counting missing days for you. ⁵²Corrector’s addition from the parallels, where the added text represents the main argument. Here the addition is irrelevant.[Will not your son Solomon build the Temple to sacrifice? Law and justice that you are upholding is more to my liking than sacrifices, as it is said⁵³Prov. 21:3., upholding justice and law is preferred by the Eternal to sacrifice.] Rav Huna said, the entire six months during which David was in flight before his son Absalom, his sins would have been atoned for by a female goat as for a commoner⁵⁴This statement is from Horaiot3:3, Note 111. Since during Absalom’s revolt David was not ruling as a king, the 40½ years of his reign actually were only 40 years of rule.. Rebbi Yudan ben Rebbi Shalom said, it is written⁵⁵1K. 11:16., for six months dwelt there Joab and all of Israel. The Holy One, praise to Him, said to him: I did tell you, do not attack them⁵⁶Deut. 2:5., but you desired to attack them. By your life, they will not be counted for you⁵⁷Therefore the 41 years are recorded as 40..

Also you say that Joab was of the opinion that the horns of an altar give asylum⁸⁷1K. 2:28, Babli 12a. but only its top gives asylum; in fact only the top of the one in Shilo gives asylum, but that of the Temple does not give asylum. But I am saying that neither the altar gives asylum, nor does its top give asylum, nor the one in Shilo gives asylum, nor that of the Temple gives asylum. Nothing except the six cities of refuge give asylum. Is it possible that Joab, about whom it is written, the most wise, head of the third⁸⁸2S. 23:8. Joab himself is not mentioned in the Chapter. Targum Jonathan and the Babli (Moˋed qatan 16b) read the expression as referring to David. should err in this matter? Rebbi Tanḥuma said, he fled to the Sanhedrin, because it is stated: The property of people executed by the court goes to their heirs; the property of people executed by the government goes to the government⁸⁹This projects Roman practice into Jewish law.. Joab said, it is better that I should be executed by the court and my sons will inherit from me than that the king should execute me and inherit from me. When Solomon heard this he said, do I need his money? Immediately, I shall remove the blood for free⁹⁰1K. 2:31. In the MT, confirmed by LXX, וַהֲסִירֹתָ. The blood is the innocent blood of Abner and Amasa., but his money is not free. He sent through Benaiahu who smote him and killed him; they buried him in his house in the wilderness⁹¹A combination of 1K. 2:29,34.. Was his house a wilderness? But to tell you that when Joab the commander of Israel’s army died⁹²Here starts the second sheet of the Genizah fragment (G)., Israel was turned into a wilderness. If you say that he collected booty to build public baths and baths⁹³A double expression of Greek (Sanhedrin 7:19, Note 357) and Hebrew terms for public baths., this is worthy of praise. But if you say that he collected booty to support Sages and their students, it is worthy of the highest praise⁹⁴Babli Sanhedrin 49a refers to 1Chr.11:8 as proof that Joab used his riches to support scholars.. And from where that the Supreme Sanhedrin is near the altar? Do not ascend on my altar by stairs. What is written next? These are the rules of law you shall put before them⁹⁵Ex. 20:23, 21:1..

Also you say that Joab was of the opinion that the horns of an altar give asylum⁸⁷1K. 2:28, Babli 12a. but only its top gives asylum; in fact only the top of the one in Shilo gives asylum, but that of the Temple does not give asylum. But I am saying that neither the altar gives asylum, nor does its top give asylum, nor the one in Shilo gives asylum, nor that of the Temple gives asylum. Nothing except the six cities of refuge give asylum. Is it possible that Joab, about whom it is written, the most wise, head of the third⁸⁸2S. 23:8. Joab himself is not mentioned in the Chapter. Targum Jonathan and the Babli (Moˋed qatan 16b) read the expression as referring to David. should err in this matter? Rebbi Tanḥuma said, he fled to the Sanhedrin, because it is stated: The property of people executed by the court goes to their heirs; the property of people executed by the government goes to the government⁸⁹This projects Roman practice into Jewish law.. Joab said, it is better that I should be executed by the court and my sons will inherit from me than that the king should execute me and inherit from me. When Solomon heard this he said, do I need his money? Immediately, I shall remove the blood for free⁹⁰1K. 2:31. In the MT, confirmed by LXX, וַהֲסִירֹתָ. The blood is the innocent blood of Abner and Amasa., but his money is not free. He sent through Benaiahu who smote him and killed him; they buried him in his house in the wilderness⁹¹A combination of 1K. 2:29,34.. Was his house a wilderness? But to tell you that when Joab the commander of Israel’s army died⁹²Here starts the second sheet of the Genizah fragment (G)., Israel was turned into a wilderness. If you say that he collected booty to build public baths and baths⁹³A double expression of Greek (Sanhedrin 7:19, Note 357) and Hebrew terms for public baths., this is worthy of praise. But if you say that he collected booty to support Sages and their students, it is worthy of the highest praise⁹⁴Babli Sanhedrin 49a refers to 1Chr.11:8 as proof that Joab used his riches to support scholars.. And from where that the Supreme Sanhedrin is near the altar? Do not ascend on my altar by stairs. What is written next? These are the rules of law you shall put before them⁹⁵Ex. 20:23, 21:1..